See Jack Shop

What: American Crew After Shave Moisturizer

The Lowdown: What you do after your shave is just as important as what you do to get ready. Shaving, no matter how gentle, always winds up stressing out your skin. Loaded with tons of natural oils and extracts (everything from nettle leaves to chamomiles to almonds), American Crew’s After Shave Moisturizer soothes and calms your skin as well as helping stop red bumps from forming.

Yea or Nay: An enthusiastic yea. Peppery, rich, but light the smell is perfect for a guy. In fact, if this were available as a cologne, it’d probably be pretty great. But it honestly leaves skill feeling strong, but supple. Never greasy, the consistency is light (you need so little, a tube lasts forever), but you don’t need much. It leaves a fresh feel and an clean, masculine aroma.

Buy it: $8.40 on sale from $12.96 @ Drugstore.com